‘History Turns on a knife-edge.’ A review of Robyn Young’s Insurrection Trilogy 1.

This is the first of Robyn Young’s books I have read but it won’t be the last. It is historical fiction of the highest order.

I must confess to not knowing much about Robert the Bruce. This novel tells the story of a complex man caught in a maelstrom of events which shaped his life and, eventually, that of two kingdoms.

Robyn Young is a fine writer who weaves plot and character in a subtle and satisfying manner.

Bruce is forged by history and then goes on to forge it. The young Bruce is confronted with conflicts of loyalty and ambition which others may not have considered conflicts at all. The fact that he did consider them so, and the decisions he makes regarding them, stem from his own complex character. They also contribute to his development both as a man and a leader.

There is much good writing in the book. Here is one acutely observed description I can’t resist quoting. ‘The weapon was sticky with blood, the smell of it like old pennies held too long in the hand.’ Young is adept at using senses to evoke an era which was both fresher and more squalid than today.

The novel darts back and forth in time which I don’t much care for and which I don’t think adds much to plot or narrative. I liked the idea that Edward used the prophecies of Merlin as a motive for his brutal invasions of Wales and Scotland. However, I imagine that he would have used the prophecies as a cloak for his naked ambition. Except that maybe Edward knew deep down that the best way to delude others is to delude oneself first.

There are some excellent supporting characters in this novel and I look forward to reading more about them as much as about Bruce himself.

I would have loved to give this book 4.5 stars but will have to content myself with 4 stars instead.

I have quoted from Robyn Young as the title of this piece because I believe it sums up the novel so exactly.

I look forward to reading the sequel which is out in August 2012.


About Martin Lake

Martin Lake lives in the French Riviera with his wife. After studying at the University of East Anglia he worked as a teacher, trainer and company director. A serious accident shattered his arm and meant that he had to rein back his work. He decided to concentrate on writing and is now writing full-time. He writes a wide range of fiction. His main interests are historical fiction, short stories and fiction for young adults. Martin has a series of novels 'The Lost King' which are set in the years following the Norman Invasion of England. They concern Edgar Atheling, last representative of the ancient English royal dynasty and his fight to regain the throne from William the Conqueror. Martin has also published 'Artful' the further adventures of the Dodger and 'Outcasts' a novel about fall of the Crusader Kingdom of Jerusalem. His latest novel, 'A Love Most Dangerous' is about a maid of honour who becomes the lover of Henry VIII. Martin’s work has been broadcast on radio. He won first prize in the Kenneth Grahame Society competition to write a story based on 'The Wind in the Willows.' You can get the collection, 'The Wind in the Willows Short Stories' from Amazon.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to ‘History Turns on a knife-edge.’ A review of Robyn Young’s Insurrection Trilogy 1.

  1. nick sayers says:


    as to whether Edward believes in the prophecies, that’s an interesting point and one which becomes more important as the trilogy develops – so do read on! Very pleased that you enjoyed this super book, though as the publisher, I’m biased!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s